Phylogeny and evolution of dorsal pattern in the Mexican endemic lizard genus Barisia (Anguidae : Gerrhonotinae)

Abstract

The phylogeny of the Mexican lizard genus Barisia was assessed using an 878 bp fragment of the mtDNA ND4 gene and a section of associated tRNA genes, as well as 16 external morphological characters. The terminal taxa comprised the currently recognized members of Barisia, including the four subspecies of the polytypic Barisia imbricata and individuals from different populations of the widespread B. i. imbricata and Barisia i. ciliaris, although for Barisia levicollis only morphology could be examined. The 'step-matrix frequency' and the 'step-matrix gap-weighting' coding approaches were employed simultaneously for the morphological data set, and three different scaling methods were evaluated for the last approach. Maximum parsimony (MP) analyses were performed for the separate and combined data sets and Bayesian analysis was also performed for the mtDNA sequence data. The hypothesis obtained from the simultaneous MP analysis strongly supports the monophyly of Barisia, but the 'exclusivity' of B. imbricata as well as of B. i. imbricata and B. i. ciliaris were not recovered. Moreover, inclusion of the morphological data showed B. levicollis nested within a clade together with the taxa assigned to B. i. ciliaris. This, together with the genetic distances and geographic concordance among the haplotypes examined, confirms that B. imbricata represents several species, although the actual species limits in this composite taxon are still unclear. Applying previously published rates of molecular evolution to the mtDNA data gives ages of divergence similar to the times proposed for some Pleistocene-Miocene geological and climatic phenomena that occurred in the Mexican territory. Variation of the dorsal pattern within Barisia was mapped onto the simultaneous morphological and molecular phylogeny, indicating that the two main states present in the taxa assigned to B. imbricata, an adult dorsal pattern present in females and absent in males and the absence of any pattern in both sexes, occur each in separate lineages. This suggests a possible scenario, where sexual dichromatism within Barisia has been repeatedly lost in different lineages.